CO129-340 - Governor Nathan Acting Governor May - 1907 [4-6] — Page 322

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

318

the 17th November.

Fr. Slade replied that there were several reasons.

First of all they naturally anticipated that the Crown would join them as respondents; the Crown knew of their existence and that they were assignees of this property; their title-deeds were on the register.

The Chief Justice grants the title.

There is no title; the Crown

Mr. Slade contended that they had a title and that it was on register, and it was hardly credible that the Crown Solicitor did not make a search to find out if there were assignees. The proper course would have been for the Crown to join them. Then they had two good rights in this land. It was perfectly obvious to anyone who had read the evidence taken in the Court below that, unless the Crown adduced further evidence they could not possibly succeed, and it was not until the 13th instant they obtained leave to adduce fresh evidence; until that time there did not appear to be any necessity for the assignees to put themselves to the expense of being made parties to the suit, believing that the Crown were not going to adduce fresh evidence. As soon as the Crown got this leave it became of vital importance to these assignees that they should be made parties, and an application was accordingly made. It was not their fault that the Crown, before getting their leave to adduce fresh evidence, and before filing affidavits, had already got a day fixed for the hearing of the case; it was a reversal of the ordinary practice. Coming to the merits of the case, the position of the assignees was set forth in the affidavit by Mr. Deacon filed on the 18th November, their solicitor. For the two applicants, by an Agreement dated 16th January 1901, between two other men and the two applicants, the latter purchased from the former.

2.

Edit History

2026-06-04 11:04:30 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
318 the 17th November. Fr. Slade replied that there were several reasons. First of all they naturally anticipated that the Crown would join them as respondents; the Crown knew of their existence and that they were assignees of this property; their title-deeds were on the register. The Chief Justice grants the title. There is no title; the Crown Mr. Slade contended that they had a title and that it was on register, and it was hardly credible that the Crown Solicitor did not make a search to find out if there were assignees. The proper course would have been for the Crown to join them. Then they had two good rights in this land. It was perfectly obvious to anyone who had read the evidence taken in the Court below that, unless the Crown adduced further evidence they could not possibly succeed, and it was not until the 13th instant they obtained leave to adduce fresh evidence; until that time there did not appear to be any necessity for the assignees to put themselves to the expense of being made parties to the suit, believing that the Crown were not going to adduce fresh evidence. As soon as the Crown got this leave it became of vital importance to these assignees that they should be made parties, and an application was accordingly made. It was not their fault that the Crown, before getting their leave to adduce fresh evidence, and before filing affidavits, had already got a day fixed for the hearing of the case; it was a reversal of the ordinary practice. Coming to the merits of the case, the position of the assignees was set forth in the affidavit by Mr. Deacon filed on the 18th November, their solicitor. For the two applicants, by an Agreement dated 16th January 1901, between two other men and the two applicants, the latter purchased from the former. 2.
Baseline (Original)
318 the 17th November. Fr.Slade replied that there was several reasons. First of all they naturally anticipated that the Crown would join them as respondents; the Crown knew of their existence and that they were assignees of this property; their title-deeds were on the register. The Chief Justice. grants the tiție. - There is no title; the Crown wr.slade contended that they had a title and that it was on register, and it was hardly credible that the Crown Belicitor did not make a seach to find out if there word assignee. The proper course would have ben for the Crow to join them. Then they had tw hole rights in this land. It was perfectly obvious to anyone who had read the evidouco taken in the Court below that wl-Ro the Cron adduced fucher ovidence they could not pogubly succeed, and it was not witil 13th instant they obtain.d leave to adduce frush, evidenou; until that vino there did not ap- pear to be my necessity for the aurignons to put themsel- you to the expune of being made parties to the sult,be- liuring that the Crom vore not going to adduce fresh evi- dence As soon as the Crown got this leave it becaan of vital importance to these assigneos that they should be mado parties, and an agrlication wa (ocordingly ads, It ves mob their fuoli timat the Crown before getting theih lave to adduco freun evidenc, and before filing affidavits had already got a day fixed for the hearing of the caNO; it was a reversal of the ordinary practics, Coming to the morits of the cube, the position of the buigre van get forth in the affiávil by Me.Deacon filed on the 18th November, to vas solicitor for the two applicants by an Agro ment daved 46ll Jen eg 1901 between two other men and the two epplicants the lattor purchoucd from the former 2.
2026-06-04 11:04:30 · Baseline
View content

318

the 17th November.

Fr.Slade replied that there was several reasons.

First of all they naturally anticipated that the Crown

would join them as respondents; the Crown knew of their

existence and that they were assignees of this property;

their title-deeds were on the register.

The Chief Justice.

grants the tiție.

-

There is no title; the Crown

wr.slade contended that they had a title and that it

was on register, and it was hardly credible that the

Crown Belicitor did not make a seach to find out if there

word assignee. The proper course would have ben for the

Crow to join them. Then they had tw hole rights in this

land. It was perfectly obvious to anyone who had read the

evidouco taken in the Court below that wl-Ro the Cron

adduced fucher ovidence they could not pogubly succeed,

and it was not witil 13th instant they obtain.d leave to

adduce frush, evidenou; until that vino there did not ap-

pear to be my necessity for the aurignons to put themsel-

you to the expune of being made parties to the sult,be-

liuring that the Crom vore not going to adduce fresh evi-

dence As soon as the Crown got this leave it becaan of

vital importance to these assigneos that they should be

mado parties, and an agrlication wa (ocordingly ads, It

ves mob their fuoli timat the Crown before getting theih

lave to adduco freun evidenc, and before filing affidavits

had already got a day fixed for the hearing of the caNO;

it was a reversal of the ordinary practics, Coming to the

morits of the cube, the position of the buigre van get

forth in the affiávil by Me.Deacon filed on the 18th

November, to vas solicitor for the two applicants by an

Agro ment daved 46ll Jen eg 1901 between two other men and

the two epplicants the lattor purchoucd from the former

2.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.